Technology is used throughout appraisal practice. An appraiser may use a spreadsheet to apply a recognized method, statistical software to analyze data, an automated valuation model to obtain information, or a generative artificial intelligence system to organize research or assist with report preparation.
In response to the expanding use of these tools, the Appraisal Standards Board adopted Advisory Opinion 41, “Use of Technology in an Appraisal or Appraisal Review Assignment” on April 23, 2026. AO-41 addresses the appraiser’s responsibilities under USPAP when technology is used in developing or communicating assignment results.
The opinion states that it “does not establish new standards or interpret existing standards.” Instead, it illustrates how principles already contained in USPAP—including the ETHICS RULE, COMPETENCY RULE, SCOPE OF WORK RULE, and RECORD KEEPING RULE—apply when technology is used. (AO-41, p. 1.) 1
AO-41 applies to real property, personal property, and intangible property appraisal practice. It is not limited to generative AI. The opinion discusses spreadsheets, regression and statistical software, automated valuation models, machine learning systems, and artificial intelligence. (AO-41, pp. 1, 3.) 2
AO-41 states that an appraiser must comply with USPAP when the service or the appraiser is required to do so by law, regulation, or agreement with the client. (AO-41, p. 3.) The Appraisal Foundation likewise explains that USPAP applicability may depend on state law, agency requirements, client contracts, or professional membership requirements. 1
Accordingly, AO-41 should not be presented as though it imposes identical obligations on every ASA member. Applicability may differ by discipline, jurisdiction, client, assignment type, and credentialing framework. The opinion provides a common framework for considering technology; it does not make the methods, evidence, or reporting requirements identical across Business Valuation, Machinery & Technical Specialties, Real Property, Personal Property, Gems & Jewelry, and Appraisal Review & Management.
The examples may also have different practical significance. A real property appraiser may use an AVM or regression model. A Business Valuation professional may work with financial models or systems that project cash flows. A Personal Property appraiser may analyze auction data, while a Gems & Jewelry appraiser may use specialized databases or technical information. The relevant question is how the tool was used and what role it played in the assignment.
AO-41 distinguishes between tool output and assignment results. USPAP defines assignment results as an appraiser’s opinions or conclusions developed in an assignment. Tool output is not an assignment result simply because it contains a number, analysis, suggested conclusion, or generated narrative. (AO-41, pp. 4–5.)
The appraiser decides whether to use a tool, whether to rely on its output, and whether that reliance supports credible assignment results for the intended use. If an appraiser relies on output without applying independent analysis consistent with the scope of work, the work does not comply with USPAP. (AO-41, p. 4.)
The opinion differentiates between tools that are transparent and tools whose internal processes may be hidden or inaccessible. A spreadsheet constructed with appraiser-selected data and formulas may function as an extension of the appraiser’s analytical process. Automated or proprietary systems may collect data, apply logic, or perform calculations in ways that are less visible to the user. Regardless of transparency, the output remains information until the appraiser evaluates its relevance and determines whether reliance is warranted. (AO-41, pp. 5–6.)
AO-41 does not generally require an appraiser to reverse engineer a tool. It does require sufficient knowledge and experience to use the tool competently, recognize relevant limitations, and assess whether the output is credible for the assignment. (AO-41, p. 6.)
AO-41 identifies three points at which technology may enter an assignment: researching, analyzing, and applying methods and techniques. A browser may provide access to market data; statistical software may assist with analysis; and a spreadsheet may help apply or present the cost, sales comparison, or income approaches. (AO-41, pp. 4–5.)
The use of a tool does not by itself require reliance on its output. The appraiser must evaluate the tool, the data and assumptions it uses, the need for independent analysis, and the credibility of the output. AO-41 states that credible results must be supported by relevant evidence and logic, not by the tool alone. (AO-41, pp. 5–6.)
The opinion also addresses tools with limited transparency. Such tools may be used, but the appraiser remains responsible for understanding enough about their purpose, assumptions, limitations, and operation to determine whether the output can support credible results. (AO-41, pp. 6, 11–12.)
AO-41 does not require an appraiser to identify every tool used during assignment development. It states that USPAP does not require disclosure merely because a tool was used. The need for disclosure depends on whether omitting the tool’s role would prevent the appraiser from communicating the assignment results clearly, accurately, and without misleading intended users. (AO-41, p. 8.)
Disclosure may be relevant when a proprietary algorithm, generative AI system, or regression model materially contributes to an analysis or suggested adjustment. In such circumstances, the appraiser may need to explain how the tool was used and how its output was incorporated into the assignment results. Depending on the assignment, relevant information may include the source data, software or service, version, date of analysis, and the tool’s role in the reasoning. (AO-41, pp. 8–9.)
Tools used only to prepare or present a report are treated differently. AO-41 identifies formatting, grammar, spelling, and text-generation tools that do not contribute to the appraiser’s analyses, opinions, or conclusions. When such tools perform only non-analytical tasks, USPAP does not require that they be named or described in the report. (AO-41, p. 9.)
The distinction is functional rather than based solely on the tool’s label. A generative AI system used for proofreading may have a different role from one used to develop market analysis or an adjustment. The reporting question is whether the tool affected the assignment results or whether identifying its use is necessary for intended users to understand the work performed.
The RECORD KEEPING RULE requires a workfile containing the information and documentation necessary to support the appraiser’s opinions and conclusions and to show compliance with USPAP. (AO-41, p. 10.)
When a tool’s output was relied upon in developing an assignment result, the workfile should contain enough information to show how the output contributed to the appraiser’s reasoning. AO-41 identifies possible documentation such as the output, related data, prompts or instructions, and analysis explaining how the output was used. The opinion generally does not require retention of internal code, algorithms, or technical specifications. (AO-41, pp. 10, 13.)
If the tool was reviewed but not relied upon, the documentation depends on the scope of work, peer expectations, and intended-user expectations. Notes explaining why the output was not used may be appropriate when that decision affected the assignment. Tools used solely for non-analytical tasks generally do not require documentation under the RECORD KEEPING RULE. (AO-41, pp. 10, 13–14.)
Technology does not lessen confidentiality obligations. Before entering confidential information into a tool, the appraiser must take reasonable steps to prevent improper disclosure. If adequate safeguards cannot be established, the information must not be entered. (AO-41, pp. 9–10.)
AO-41 also addresses client restrictions and requirements. A client may prohibit a technology or require analysis of a particular tool’s output, but the resulting scope of work must still support credible assignment results. If a restriction or requirement prevents USPAP compliance, the appraiser must address the issue with the client, modify the scope where appropriate, decline the assignment, or withdraw. (AO-41, pp. 7–8.)
AO-41 therefore provides a framework rather than a universal technology policy. Tools may continue to change, but the appraiser’s responsibility for competent analysis, appropriate scope of work, confidentiality, communication, and credible assignment results remains.